Search Books

  • Search Full Site
  • Display Book Titles
  • Display Book Paragraphs
2 paragraphs found in the 1 Book listed below
The Character and Logical Method of Political Economy; Cairnes, John Elliot
2 paragraphs found.
Lecture VII, Of the Malthusian Doctrine of Population
VII.10

Armed with the same principle Malthus was enabled to give a complete and philosophic answer to the communistic plans which were at that time ardently advocated by Godwin, Owen, and others, by showing that, as such schemes offered no inducement to the exercise of prudential restraint, and removed those which already existed, they were defective just in that point without which human improvement was impossible: they provided no security against a redundant population,—none, therefore, against the want and misery which a redundant population must occasion.

Note:
As a specimen of the intelligence exhibited in criticisms of Malthus, take the following from Blanqui's Histoire de l'Économie Politique:—"Le choix que Malthus a fait de l'Amérique, o� la population double tous les vingt-cinq ans, n'est pas plus concluant que celui de la Suède, o�, selon M. Godwin, elle ne double que tous les cent ans. Les sociétés ne procèdent point ainsi par périodes regulières, comme les astres et les saisons, etc." Malthus could find his opponents in arguments, but not in brains.