A Conversation with Anthony de Jasay
Anthony de Jasay, a regular columnist for Econlib, was one of the most original and independent thinkers on the relationship between the individual and the state. Through his published works, he challenged the reigning paradigms justifying modern democratic growth. His deeply challenging theoretical works include The State, an analysis that views the state as acting primarily in its own interests and often in opposition to the interests of both society and individuals. His other works include Social Contract, Free Ride: A Study of the Public Goods Problem; Against Politics; and Political Economy, Concisely. In this 2000 interview with Hartmut Kliemt, he discusses his work which has become known for its insightful, individualistic, and unconventional analysis of power, politics, and freedom.
Below are some discussion prompts and other materials related to this video:
4:43 Oxford and Keynes
1- What was the inspiration for de Jasay’s critique of Keynes, and what was the substance of his critique?
2- After retiring from a career in finance, de Jasay turned once again to writing. What factors does he note as prompting his desire to write The State?
13:40 The Minimal State
3- de Jasay says he does not believe that achieving the minimal state is possible. In what two ways does he suggest the notion of the minimal state can be undermined? Is de Jasay too pessimistic? Explain.
4- Kliemt asks de Jasay if there is an inherent tension between his methodological individualism and his apparent assumption of unitary power in The State. How does de Jasay respond, and how convincing is his response?
5- How did James Buchanan influence the trajectory of The State?
6- Why does de Jasay describe contractarianism (like that of Buchanan) as a “logic trap?” What is the “myth of legitimation?”
26:28 The Role of the Political Philosopher
7- Kliemt presses de Jasay on why he feels we should not advocate for “better” government, but de Jasay insists we should neither welcome nor approve of a government which is tolerable. Why, and to what extent do you find this position reasonable?
30:59 On Constitutions and America
8- Why does de Jasay think most people have a totally unjustified faith in constitutions? To what extent do you agree with him?
9- de Jasay says America is “an unbelievably lucky country.” What reasons does he give for this, and how true is his claim?
36:25 Anarchist or Reluctant Archist?
10- While de Jasay calls himself an anarchist, he does offer a caveat. What is it? How does his view of anarchy’s possibility vary over the short and long term?
11- Why does de Jasay insist that collective choice will always be able to preempt individual choice? How does his perspective differ from that of Buchanan?
43:23 Private Contract Enforcement
12- de Jasay believes contract enforcement can still exist in the absence of the state. How does he think this would work, and how plausible do you find this explanation?
13- de Jasay says, “The world is always a small place. This is where I differ from Hayek.” What does he mean by this? With whom would you agree?
14- What would be the role of “mutual help” in stateless contract enforcement, according to de Jasay?
15- Explain why de Jasay notes it’s fashionable, yet misleading, to point to transaction costs in justifying a role for the state.
59:05 The Return of the Free Rider
16- How has the introduction of the “prisoners’ dilemma” made justifications for the state more sophisticated, according to de Jasay?
17- How does paying our taxes encourage free-riding, according to de Jasay?
18- How does de Jasay distinguish between a “right” and a “liberty?” To what extent is his distinction accurate and helpful?
de Jasay’s The State.
de Jasay’s Political Economy, Concisely.
de Jasay’s Justice and Its Surroundings.
The Best of the Online Library of Liberty, “Anthony de Jasay, ‘Liberalism and Democracy‘ (1985).
Liberty Matters, Anthony de Jasay and the Political Economy of the State.
Entries from the Concise Encyclopedia of Economics:
- John Maynard Keynes biography.
- John Hicks biography.
- Prisoners’ Dilemma, by Avinash Dixit and Barry Nalebuff.
- Keynesian Economics, by Alan Blinder.
- Fiscal Policy, by David Weil.
- Microeconomics, by Arnold Harberger.
- Archive of Anthony de Jasay’s columns on EconLib.
- Michael Munger, Anthony de Jasay: A Remembrance
- Pierre Lemieux, An Unavoidable Theory of the State
- Fazzari on Keynesian Economics: http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2009/01/fazzari_on_keyn.html
- Reis on Keynes, Macroeconomics, and Monetary Policy: http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2009/04/reis_on_keynes.html