"Social Welfare Groups" Defined in the Process of Their Emergence
By Art Carden
One of my favorite essays in the social sciences is James Buchanan’s very short “Order Defined in the Process of its Emergence.” It probably has the highest ratio of insight-to-text of any article I’ve ever read, and I come back to it often–particularly in light of events like the recent scandal in which the IRS “singled out conservative groups for special scrutiny” when they applied for tax exempt status.
It’s easy (and perhaps intuitive) to say things like “tax-exempt groups shouldn’t be allowed to engage in political activity” or “education produces positive externalities and should therefore be subsidized.” But what is “political activity”? What is “education”? My definitions may be very different from yours. Paying the armies of lawyers necessary to work this out might actually cost more than the purported benefits of the restriction or the subsidy, and these aren’t terms with objective definitions that lie waiting to be discovered. They are constantly in flux, with new types of political activity and education emerging as people come up with ever-more creative responses to the world around them. They are defined in the process of their emergence.
What are other examples of phenomena, products, organizations, or ideas that are defined in the process of their emergence?